Title: Why Starkiller Base in Star Wars Makes No Sense According to Fans
Content:
The Flaw in Starkiller Base:
Introduction:
Starkiller Base, a giant superweapon in the Star Wars universe, has sparked much debate among fans. Serving as a replacement for the infamous Death Star, Starkiller Base is not without its flaws. One of the major issues that fans have pointed out is the questionable physics behind the base’s ability to destroy planets at such immense distances in a short amount of time.
The Debate Among Fans:
Unintentional Humor:
A scene in the movie where a hologram illustrates the size comparison between Starkiller Base and the Death Star unintentionally adds a layer of humor. The sheer scale of Starkiller Base compared to its predecessor raises eyebrows, contributing to the disbelief among fans.
Physicists vs. Star Wars Science:
Reddit users have delved into the science (or lack thereof) behind Starkiller Base’s capabilities. One user highlighted the issue of how the base’s destructive beam could reach planets lightyears away in mere moments. The argument presented is that light, which serves as a medium of visibility, takes thousands of years to traverse such distances, casting doubt on the feasibility of the destruction depicted in the movie.
Novelization Insights:
Dark Energy Explanation:
The Star Wars novelization offers a more detailed explanation for how Starkiller Base operates. Unlike the movie’s portrayal of the base drawing energy from a star, the novel describes a system that harnesses dark energy, storing it within the planet’s core before releasing it through a subspace wormhole. This concept of using dark energy instead of draining a star sheds light on the base’s destructive capabilities.
Clarifying the Confusion:
While the novel provides clarity on the inner workings of Starkiller Base, this information is not readily available to viewers who solely rely on the movie for context. The disparity between the movie’s presentation and the novel’s explanation can lead to confusion among fans, especially when it comes to the scientific plausibility of such a weapon in the Star Wars universe.
Conclusion:
Accepting the Inexplicable:
In a franchise filled with fantastical elements like lightsabers and the Force, some fans are willing to overlook scientific inaccuracies in favor of enjoying the storytelling. However, the introduction of Starkiller Base pushes the boundaries for some fans, prompting discussions on the feasibility of such a weapon within the established Star Wars universe.